Rutherford LOCKSMITH INC
Locksmith Service

Residential Locksmith Services in Rutherford & the Rutherford area

When you're locked out of your house in the Five Towns or standing on your porch in Far Rockaway realizing your keys are inside, you need a locksmith who actually answers the phone and shows up fast. Rutherford Locksmith Inc is a 24/7 mobile residential locksmith serving Cedarhurst, Lawrence, Woodmere, Inwood, Hewlett, Far Rockaway, Long Beach and the neighborhoods around JFK — we come to you, day or night, with the tools to get you back inside without tearing your door apart.

Open 24 hours, 7 days a week · Licensed, bonded & insured

Whether you've moved into a new place near Central Avenue and want every lock rekeyed, you're considering a smart lock for your beach-block rental in Long Beach, or your deadbolt finally gave out after years of salt air, we handle it. We're licensed, bonded and insured, and we confirm the exact price with you up front — before any work begins — so there are no surprises when the job is done.

4.7 / 5.0
58 Google reviews
Insured Technicians
Background-checked pros
24/7 Service
Day, night & weekends
Up-Front Pricing
Clear quote before work starts

What we do

Same-Day Lockouts

We reach most Rutherford addresses within 30 minutes to get you back inside without damaging the door.

High-Security Deadbolts

Grade 1 and bump-resistant deadbolts sized for the vintage door frames common on Union and Park Avenue homes.

Tenant Turnover Rekeys

Fast rekeying for landlords between renters so old keys stop working the same day.

Smart Lock Setup

We install and pair keypad and Wi-Fi locks, then walk you through the app before we leave.

01

Locked Out of the House? Fast, Damage-Free Entry

Getting locked out of your house is one of the most stressful — and most common — calls we get. Maybe the door swung shut behind you while you were taking out the trash, a key snapped off in the cylinder, or you're locked out of the house with no key at all because the only set is sitting on the kitchen counter. Whatever happened, our mobile techs are dispatched throughout the Five Towns, the Rockaways and the Long Beach boardwalk area around the clock, and we aim to arrive quickly because we're already local.

Our priority on every home lockout service call is non-destructive entry. In the large majority of cases we can pick, bump or manipulate a standard residential lock open with no damage to your door, frame or hardware — meaning you're not paying to repair a kicked-in door on top of the lockout. For high-security or specialty cylinders that can't be picked safely, we'll explain your options clearly, including drilling only as a last resort and replacing the affected cylinder so you're left with a working, secure lock.

Wondering what to do if you're locked out of your house? First, check every other door and any ground-floor window — and make sure you're safe and not in the cold or heat for long. Then call us at (516) 346-5505. We'll ask a few quick questions (your address, the type of lock, whether you have ID showing residency), give you an honest arrival estimate and confirm the price before we head over. For everyone's protection, we do verify that you live at or have the right to access the property.

locksmith — Rutherford Locksmith Inc
02

Rekeying vs. Replacing Your Locks — Which One Do You Actually Need?

A lot of homeowners assume they need brand-new hardware when really they just need their existing locks rekeyed. So how does rekeying a lock work? A locksmith removes the lock cylinder, swaps out the internal pins and springs to match a new key, and reassembles it — the result is that the old keys no longer work and you get a fresh set. The lock body, the finish, the deadbolt itself all stay exactly as they are. Lock rekeying is faster and almost always cheaper than buying and installing new locks, which is why it's the right call in most situations.

Rekeying makes the most sense when your locks are in good working order but you simply can't trust who else has a key — after a move, a breakup, a contractor job, or losing a key ring. If you've got several doors keyed to different keys, we can also key them all alike so one key opens everything. A full lock change (replacing the hardware entirely) is the better choice when the lock is worn out, damaged, low-grade, or you want to upgrade to a higher security grade or a different style or finish.

If you've been searching 'rekey locks near me' or 'rekey a lock,' here's roughly what to expect: rekeying typically runs a modest per-cylinder fee plus a service call, and most homes have somewhere between two and six cylinders. Replacing locks costs more because you're paying for the new hardware too. These are estimates that vary with the lock type, brand and how many doors you have — we'll always look at your actual locks, give you a firm quote and confirm it with you before we touch anything.

locksmith — Rutherford Locksmith Inc
03

Deadbolts & High-Security Lock Installation

A quality deadbolt is the single most cost-effective security upgrade for most homes, and around here it matters more than people think — the salt air off the Atlantic in Long Beach and Far Rockaway is hard on cheap hardware, corroding pins and seizing cylinders within a few seasons. We install and service Grade 1 and Grade 2 deadbolts from trusted manufacturers, and we make sure the strike plate is anchored into the framing with long screws, not just the doorjamb, so the lock can actually resist a forced entry.

For homeowners who want stronger protection, we install high-security cylinders with restricted, patented keyways. These resist picking and bumping, and just as importantly, the keys can't be copied at a hardware store or kiosk — duplicates are controlled, so you always know exactly how many keys exist and who has them. That's a meaningful upgrade for anyone who's had keys floating around or shares a multi-family home.

Many older homes throughout the Five Towns and the Rockaways still have mortise locks — those heavy, built-in lock bodies set into the edge of the door. We service and rebuild mortise hardware and can also fit a mortise smart lock where you want keyless convenience without losing that classic look. If your current setup is rattling, sticking or no longer latching cleanly, we'll diagnose whether it needs adjustment, a new cylinder or a full replacement, and lay out the options honestly.

locksmith — Rutherford Locksmith Inc
04

Smart Locks & Keyless Entry

Smart lock installation is one of our fastest-growing residential requests, and for good reason — no more hiding a key under the mat, easy temporary codes for guests, dog walkers or your cleaner, and a phone notification when the kids get home from school. We install keypad deadbolts, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth models, and integrations that work with the major smart-home platforms, and we'll walk you through the day-to-day so you're not left guessing how to set up codes.

Not every door or every household is right for every model, and that's where having a real locksmith — rather than a box-store DIY install — pays off. We check that your door is properly aligned and that the bolt throws fully before we install, because a misaligned door will drain batteries and cause a smart lock to jam. If you have a mortise door, we'll point you to a mortise smart lock built for that application instead of forcing a standard deadbolt unit where it doesn't belong.

A smart lock is a great convenience, but it's only as secure as the hardware behind it, so we still emphasize a solid bolt, a reinforced strike and good door fit. We're also realistic about batteries and backups: most quality smart locks include a physical key override or external power contacts, and we'll make sure you have a manual way in if the battery dies. As always, we confirm the full price — hardware plus installation — before we begin.

locksmith — Rutherford Locksmith Inc
05

Just Moved In? Your New-Home Security Checklist

Closing on a house or signing a lease near Cedarhurst, Inwood or the Long Beach boardwalk is exciting — and it's also the moment you have the least idea who holds a key to your new place. Previous owners, their relatives, real estate agents, contractors and old tenants may all have copies. The first thing we recommend for any new move-in is a full lock rekeying so every existing key stops working and you start fresh with keys only you control.

While we're there, we do a quick walkthrough of every exterior door and recommend practical upgrades: a proper deadbolt on any door that lacks one, longer strike-plate screws, and securing secondary entries like garage side doors, basement doors and patio sliders that buyers often overlook. If the home has multiple doors on different keys, we'll key them alike so you carry one key instead of a crowded ring.

This is also the ideal time to think about smart locks and keyless entry, especially for rental and vacation properties common in the Rockaways and Long Beach, where you may be issuing codes to guests rather than handing out keys. We'll give you straight advice on what's worth doing now versus later, provide a written estimate, and confirm it with you before any work starts — no pressure to buy more than you need.

locksmith — Rutherford Locksmith Inc
06

Eviction Lockouts, Window Gates & Landlord Services

We provide lock changes and rekeying for landlords and property managers handling tenant turnover and court-ordered eviction lockouts throughout the Five Towns and JFK area. When a tenancy ends, the responsible move is a fast lock change or rekey so the unit is secure for the next occupant. For eviction lockouts specifically, we require the proper legal documentation and coordination with the marshal or law enforcement as applicable — we don't change locks on an occupied unit without the correct authority, both to protect you and to keep everything above board.

Many homes and ground-floor apartments around Far Rockaway and Inwood use window gates and security bars, and we install, repair and replace these as well. We can fit gates with quick-release mechanisms that keep intruders out while still allowing a fast exit in an emergency — an important safety detail that's sometimes missing on older gates. If your existing gate locks are rusted, sticking or you've lost the key, we can service or rekey them so they actually function when you need them.

For multi-unit buildings we also handle master key systems, common-entry hardware and mailbox locks. Whether you own one rental near Central Avenue or manage several units, we'll assess the property, recommend a sensible keying plan and give you a clear, confirmed price up front. We're licensed, bonded and insured, so you've got the right paperwork backing every job.

locksmith — Rutherford Locksmith Inc

Brands We Service

We install, repair and rekey all major lock brands — from everyday deadbolts to high-security cylinders.

  • Schlage logo
  • Kwikset logo
  • Medeco logo
  • Emtek logo
  • Baldwin logo
  • Yale logo

Don’t see your brand? We service virtually every make — just call.

Reviews

What Rutherford & the Rutherford area Customers Say

4.7 ★★★★★ 4 reviews
★★★★★
“This is the best locksmith in my area. I walked into the shop one day and had two keyed knobs and deadbolts installed the next day. Jeff is very knowledgeable and answered all of my questions. The install was a breeze and my home was treated with respect. It was a quality job at a good price, what more could I ask for? This is the only locksmith I will go to.”
I
Ivan Stosic
5 years ago · Google review
C Christopher Wanko ★★★★★
M Mike Saffert ★★★★★
J Jasmine Lee ★★★★★

Service area

Areas we cover around Rutherford

Based in Rutherford, we reach the Rutherford area fast — 24/7. Don’t see your street? Call us, we very likely cover it.

(201) 554-1344

Frequently asked questions

Answers to what our customers ask most. Still unsure? Just call.

How fast can you get to me if I'm locked out of my house?+

Because we're a local mobile locksmith covering the Five Towns, Far Rockaway, Long Beach and the JFK area, we can usually reach you quickly, day or night. When you call (516) 346-5505 we'll give you an honest arrival estimate based on your exact location and current demand. We never promise an unrealistic time just to win the call.

Can you open my door without damaging it?+

In most residential lockouts, yes — we use professional picking and manipulation techniques to open standard locks with no damage to the door, frame or hardware. Some high-security cylinders can't be opened that way, and in rare cases drilling is the only safe option, but we always explain that first and replace any cylinder we have to drill. Damage-free entry is our default goal on every call.

Should I rekey or replace my locks after moving in?+

For most new homeowners and tenants, rekeying is the smarter choice: it invalidates all the old keys, gives you fresh keys you control, and costs less than buying new hardware. Replacement makes sense when the locks are worn, damaged, low-grade or you want to upgrade the style, finish or security level. We'll look at your actual locks and recommend whichever genuinely serves you best.

How much does it cost to rekey a lock?+

Rekeying typically involves a modest per-cylinder charge plus a service call, and most homes have several cylinders, so the total depends on how many doors you have and the lock brand. A full lock change costs more because it includes new hardware. These are estimates that vary — we always inspect your locks and confirm the exact price with you before starting any work.

Do I need to be home for a rekey or lock change?+

Yes, for rekeying and lock changes we need someone with the authority to access the property present, and for lockouts we verify that you live at or have the right to enter the address. This protects you and prevents misuse. Bringing ID that shows your address speeds everything up.

Are smart locks actually secure?+

A quality smart lock from a reputable brand, installed on a properly aligned door with a solid deadbolt and reinforced strike plate, is secure and very convenient. The weak points are usually poor door fit, low-grade hardware or a dead battery, which is why we check alignment and confirm there's a key or power backup before we finish. We'll recommend a model suited to your specific door, including mortise smart locks for built-in mortise doors.

Can you change locks for an eviction or tenant turnover?+

Yes, we handle lock changes and rekeying for landlords and property managers, including eviction lockouts. For evictions we require the proper legal documentation and coordination with the marshal or law enforcement when applicable — we won't change locks on an occupied unit without the correct authority. For ordinary turnover between tenants, we can rekey or replace promptly.

Are you licensed and insured?+

Yes. Rutherford Locksmith Inc is licensed, bonded and insured, and we provide clear, up-front pricing that we confirm with you before any work begins. If you ever have questions about a quote or a recommendation, just ask — we'd rather take the extra minute than leave you uncertain.

Locked out or need a lock fixed? We are on the way.

We answer 24/7 — talk to a real local locksmith now.

(201) 554-1344